Saturday, 22 January 2011

Black Swan - Holy crap!

So it's about 24 hours since I settled down into the front row of a lovely, quiet cinema screen to enjoy Black Swan.  2 hours later I staggered out, feeling as though I needed a nice lie down.  I just about feel ready to try and organise my thoughts.  I hope they make sense!



Ballet is all about balance. You must be sure-footed. Darren Aronofsky makes sure his audience is the opposite, throwing us off balance and out of our comfort zone at every opportunity.  The result is a stunning, satisfying and unexpectedly funny film.


TEENY SPOILERS MAY FOLLOW

Natalie Portman is Nina Sayers; a ballerina with the determination to be 'perfect'.  Portman apparently trained for 10 months for this role and it shows.  She has always been graceful and fragile-looking but now she looks as though she could snap at any moment. Every bone protrudes, every muscle is lean.  Right or wrong, this is what dancers go through and the commitment she has shown to get there really shouldn't be underestimated.  She should win the Oscar. It'd be a crime if she didn't.  Her performance is the thing which grounds Black Swan. It gives it it's realism. It stops it from leaping, head first,  over the top of plausible.

So Nina is cast in Swan Lake, playing the White Swan Odette and the Black Swan Odile. She's great at dancing Odette cos she's all boring and sexless but Odile is more of a challenge... Enter Vincent Cassell!


He's the slimy French choreographer and he's brilliant.  Smarmy and calculated. Nina falls for every line.

Barbara Hershey plays Nina's mother and this relationship is the most interesting in the film.  Hershey switches brilliantly between Erica's attempts to be pally; all sorority girl sharing and hair brushing; and an ultra-controlling matriarch.


Nina's real-life opposite is Lily, a new dancer from (gasp) California!  She is everything Nina isn't; relaxed, sexy and independent. An uneasy friendship is formed, with the undercurrent of competition never too far away.  Mila Kunis seems to relish this role and she can do sexy with her eyes closed.  Lily is the catalyst for Nina finally losing her cool. Kunis is, on the face of it, the opposite of Portman but they are facially at least, similar enough for us to be freaked out now and then!


As the film progresses Aronofsky really starts to have fun.  Throwing the audience completley off balance with Cronenberg-esque body horror to make you (well me anyway) squirm in your seats. The omnipresent mirrors become more and more integral to Nina's crumbling psychosis and are the basis of some great shocks. And how do you not see the cameramen?!  And a scene involving Winona Ryder (who's pretty good) will have you wondering if you've wandered into an actual horror film.


Sound is used to great effect and the realism of the film stock and camera work really offsets the seeming unreality of the events of the final act. The dance scenes are excellent.  Filmed close to show the agony and the effort rather than the grace and elegance of the finished product.

And what of the ending?  I really can't tell you about it cos it's a pretty massive spoiler which is a shame cos I had some good clever words lined up but join me in comments and we'll argue it out!

I can't recommend Black Swan highly enough. It won't be everyone's cup of tea and I'm not sure I found it totally satisfying but it's the most exciting and thrilling films I've seen in a while. The performances really do make it.

Also... aren't these posters gorgeous?  The designers hadn't seen the film when they made them but they've really captured the tone I think. I'd happily hang all of them in my house.








7 comments:

Mike Lippert said...

I'm just curious about your statement where you say you can't recommend it enough but you don't know if it is totally satisfying? Seems like a bit of a contradiction, does it not?

Jess said...

I don't think so. I really enjoyed the film and I do recommend it. I'm not sure it's perfect but what film is? I need to see it again to really figure it out I think. I recommend it because people should go and make up their own mind.

Nerd Chronicle said...

I can't make up my mind about Black Swan. It's quite difficult.

On the one hand, it was well crafted, and interesting and did not bore me at all. On the other though, Saying that I liked it doesn't really feel authentic.

I appreciated the film, and think it was well done, but would not rave about it or purchase it to watch over and over.

BUT, when compared with most of Hollywood fare, the movie is outstanding, I suppose.

Just my two cents.

Anonymous said...

Thanks to my father who stated to me cοnсеrning this web site, this
wеblοg is actuallу awesome.

My page - iphone repair bangsar

Anonymous said...

Nice poѕt. I waѕ checking constantly thіs blog and I am impreѕsеd!
Extгemely usеful info partiсularly the last
ρагt :) I carе fοr such information muсh.
I was ѕeeking this pагticular infο for а long time.
Thank you and best of lucκ.

Feel free to surf to my web-site :: repair imac retina display malaysia

Anonymous said...

Fіne ωaу of ԁescribing,
and goοԁ paгаgraрh to оbtain
information abοut my presentatіon subject, whісh i аm going tо cοnvеy іn college.



Аlsο viѕіt my webρage .
.. ipad Repair malaysia

Anonymous said...

When someone ωгites an paragraph he/she rеtainѕ the idea of a useг in his/heг mind that how a user can
be aware οf it. Ѕo that's why this article is perfect. Thanks!

Also visit my web page: ipad repair melaka